In a surprising twist at the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal, rookie Carmelo Hayes emerged victorious, outlasting a ring full of seasoned wrestlers. This victory has sparked a significant amount of controversy and discussion among fans and insiders alike. Among the voices contributing to this conversation is none other than former WWE head writer Vince Russo, who expressed his discontent with the outcome on a recent episode of “BroDown with Mac Davis.”
Controversial Opinions from Vince Russo
Vince Russo, known for his outspoken views, didn’t hold back in his critique of Hayes’ win. Russo argued that WWE missed an opportunity to elevate a returning star, suggesting that either Miro (formerly Rusev) or Aleister Black would have been more impactful choices. “This is the stuff that I mean. My God, bro, if you want to put somebody over in this, you should’ve had Miro or you should’ve had Aleister Black. You should have had somebody new. But they do this all the time. They beat somebody to death, and then they give him what they think is a big win, and they think you forgot all the losses before that. Carmelo Hayes means nothing because of the way they booked him,” Russo explained passionately during the show.
His criticism highlights a recurring issue within WWE’s storytelling tactics—building momentum for new talents. According to Russo, Hayes’ prior losses and lackluster booking diminished the significance of his win, potentially failing to convert this victory into a substantial push forward in his career.
The Battle Royal saw Carmelo Hayes and Andrade as the last two men standing, with Hayes securing his win by eliminating Andrade. The match was studded with prominent wrestlers like Shinsuke Nakamura, Rey Fenix, Otis, Chad Gable, Karrion Kross, and The Miz, each aiming to claim the coveted title. Despite the stiff competition, Hayes’ victory was met with mixed reactions, underscoring the polarized views on his push within WWE.
Moving forward, it remains to be seen whether Carmelo Hayes can leverage this controversial win to catapult himself to the top of the WWE roster. Fans and critics alike will be watching closely to see if this triumph can translate into sustained momentum or if it will be just another forgotten moment in the chaotic world of professional wrestling.
For more insights and a detailed breakdown of the Battle Royal, viewers can check out the full discussion on “BroDown with Mac Davis,” available on YouTube, and make sure to credit Sportskeeda for the transcript that provided the foundational insights for this analysis.
I am a writer with a passion for technology and gaming. I write about a variety of subjects, including Esports, Games, Shows, and Sports. I create engaging and informative content for Hiptoro.